20 User Icon

Login | Create New Account | Facebook | Twitter

Homes | Jobs | Wheels | Worship | IShopTheTri | Move To Kingsport | Kingsport Chamber of Commerce
Times-News Online
Printericon Print | Email Email |

Davis defends his vote against dogfighting bill


Published July 26th, 2007 | 8 Comments


 

In the wake of the federal dogfighting indictment against Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick, U.S. Rep. David Davis responded Wednesday to an animal rights group accusing him of giving dogfighters a “free pass” by voting against legislation last March to upgrade penalties for the illegal transportation of dogs.

The Humane Society Legislative Fund (HSLF) attacked Davis for his vote on the Animal Fighting Prohibition Enforcement Act, which passed the House by a 368-39 vote, cleared the Senate unanimously and was signed by President Bush in May — after the alleged crimes listed in an indictment against Vick and his codefendants had occurred.

Davis, R-1st District, was the only member of the Tennessee congressional delegation to vote against the bill.

“The vast majority of members of Congress supported this legislation to put a stop to precisely the type of behavior that Michael Vick was charged with last week — participation in a multi-state network of cruel and degrading dogfighting activities,” HSLF President Michael Markarian said in a prepared release. “Humane organizations and more than 400 law enforcement agencies supported the federal bill, yet David Davis showed his true colors by giving dogfighters a free pass.”

Davis responded by indicating that the Humane Society is using Vick’s situation to advance its political agenda.

“The reality is dogfighting and cockfighting are illegal in Tennessee and will continue to be illegal in Tennessee,” Davis said. “I don’t feel like you need a new federal law. You have state laws in place. It has nothing to do about my feelings for or against animals. I wish they could look at my vet bill for my dog that passed away about three months ago.”

Through its Web site (www.hsus.org), the Humane Society has started a campaign encouraging people to “tell Nike to drop Michael Vick” and is asking for donations to “help end dogfighting.”

After the seizure of more than 60 dogs following the raid on Vick’s property by local law enforcement officers, the Humane Society said it initially provided “several thousand dollars in financial assistance” to Surry County, Va., for the animals’ treatment and care.

“We sought funds to help defray the anticipated costs of sheltering 52 pit bulls among these dogs for an indefinite interval. After a federal grand jury indicted Vick and three others, the costs of caring for them became a federal responsibility. We’ve offered to provide continuing assistance, but the federal government has decided to shoulder the burden on its own from this point forward,” a Humane Society release said.

HSLF said federal prosecutors charged Vick with a felony by invoking the federal Travel Act and conspiracy on one charge, but noted Vick escaped more charges because the animal fighting allegations against him preceded the new federal law.

The new federal law makes interstate transport of animals for fighting purposes a felony offense with penalties of up to three years in prison for each violation.

Currently, 48 states have felony dogfighting laws and 35 states have felony cockfighting laws, according to HSLF. Dogfighting in Tennessee is a felony, while cockfighting is a m i s d e m e a n o r.

HSLF describes itself as a 501(c) organization formed as a separate lobbying affiliate of the Humane Society.

For more about HSLF go to www.hslf.org.

For more about Davis go to

Discuss This Story

Be the first to comment: Sign In or Create Profile .

I think some of you people are missing the real point here. First of all, Mr. Davis is supposed to represent the people, not his own oppinions. In the article he made it clear that his vote was based on his opinion, not on the wishes of the majority of his constituents. This tells me that he puts his interests in front of yours! When the good people of Tennessee voted him into office, he made promises to represent the people. This is not happening. I grew up in Kingsport, but now live in another state because Kingsport could not offer me the opportunities that I have today. One of the reasons for that is the elected officials. My point is that if a representative is not representing the majority of his constituents, then he or she needs to be voted out. If we as a voting public stood together regardless of political affiliations, then politicians would get the message. Instead, we are like lemmings, we follow whatever the leader is doing, and when that leader leads us to the edge of the cliff, we willingly jump off right behind him. If this issue is as important to you as it is to me, then it's time to stand up and say, "either support the majority, or go HOME!"

Now as to those who think we have too many laws already, your absolutely right. We do!. However, in this case,the passage of this legislation creates a forum whereas states have to cooperate in order to make their laws effective. Because laws differ from state to state, this legislation gives us a uniform directive in which all states have to comply. Therefore creating a system which is eaqually enforcable no matter what the jurisdiction.

CommentAngela Fleenor | 8/10/2007 - 12:57 PM - (CommentSuggest Removal )

Another Federal Law doesn't mean much. Just look at the bang up job the Feds do enforcing our immigration laws.

CommentDale St. John | 8/3/2007 - 2:57 AM - (CommentSuggest Removal )

Davis is right, there are already laws against this within his jurisdiction. Dogfighting is now and will remain illegal.

CommentJim Johnson | 8/2/2007 - 10:57 AM - (CommentSuggest Removal )

Once you commit a felony its a whole new world with no voting rights etc etc for the rest of your life. These folks should have to face that type of consequence for this type of behavior!

CommentDan Foster | 7/31/2007 - 4:35 PM - (CommentSuggest Removal )

Than you Mr.Davis

The federal government can stay away. States have rights

CommentBrian Haynes | 7/27/2007 - 11:21 AM - (CommentSuggest Removal )

Rep. Davis shot himself in the foot on this issue. Most people were angry and disgusted about the Michael Vick dog fighting story and felt something needed to be done. Davis could have at best made a little political capital supporting the Animal Fighting Prohibition Act and at worse not generated bad feelings toward him by animal rights advocates. This in my opinion shows his usual lack of political savvy which will haunt him througout his term in The House and make it a contentious one.

CommentJoe Allison | 7/26/2007 - 11:45 AM - (CommentSuggest Removal )

We have enough LAWS now. How many GUN lAWS do we have and people still kill people? Congressman Davis is doing a wonderful JOB. Think about how you obey the speed limit law each time you drive. Do we need more SPEED LIMIT laws? Maybe we need a Federal Speed limit Law. It might help as much as more animal laws.

CommentTracy Farmer | 7/26/2007 - 11:12 AM - (CommentSuggest Removal )

I think it good to have federal law. That way the get more prison time.There is one state where cock fighting is legal. Mr Davis is wrong on his vote. I wonder how much lobbing was done to get him to vote no. I think it should be illegal to even raise fighting cocks. You can tell where some one is raising them. The are each have a little place for them to get out rain and they are tied to a stake so they can not get to another cock. They not raise for any other reason. The people who raise them are nothing but dirt in my mind. That show you mr davis does not think like most pet owner.

Comment | 7/26/2007 - 10:00 AM - (CommentSuggest Removal )
Post a Comment

To comment, you must register.

Comments are the sole responsibility of the registered user participating in online discussions. You agree not to post comments off topic, abusive, obscene, defamatory, vulgar, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned.

Click here to review our complete user agreement.

Featured Blogger

Don Fenley

2012 doomsday myths - garbage in, garbage out

By Don Fenley - 11-18-2009
Talk about your hype machine. The Web conspiracy theorists, hype mongers and Hollywood promoters hoping to cash in on the Thanksgiving holiday movie ...
Read Post | Comments (0)

topjobs

ATTENTION FULL/PART TIME C.N.A.S
Church Hill Health Care
ATTENTION LPN'S PRN
Church Hill Health Care & Rehab
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
Holston Medical Group
MACHINE OPERATORS NEEDED
Sam Dong partnering with Staff Pro
ATTENTION FULL/PART TIME MIDNIGHT PRN-RN.SUPERVISO
Church Hill Health Care
INTERNET ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE & BRAND MANAGER
Times Digital Group
GROW YOUR CAREER
Life Center of Gray
Times-News Online on Facebook